Tuesday, November 18, 2008

33,000 default on HDB Loan....

UPDATE: There is indeed some manifestation of the socialist heart as I watched "Today in Parliament". A minister explained that those who can't pay are not immediately evicted. They are allowed to stay until all avenues are exhausted. Unfortunately, in recent years many HDB owners were encouraged by low interest rates to take up bank loans for the HDB. How will the banks handle default for HDB flats? Also, those who restructured their loans in recent years reverse the priority of the banks and CPF for repayment - if they foreclosure your home, banks get paid first. We know the banks are quite brutal for private property - your property going under the hammer once you default. If you have negative equity, you end up still owing the bank after losing your home.
.
In the US, in many states, the 1st time home buyer can just return his keys if he cannot service his loan. The bank is required by law to forgive his entire housing debt. This pushes some responsibility back to the bank to prevent overlending during housing bubbles. Unfortunate, they did overlend and they(banks) now swallowed this poison pill. In many states (in US), there is a homestead law which prevent the banks from foreclosing and seizing your assets for default on unsecured debt. This form of protection is not available in Singapore. In Singapore, banks are kings. .....not just in the minibond saga...all our laws favor the banks. It is great to be a bank in Singapore. If I find time, I'll write about the other problem caused again by MAS deregulation - unsecured debt. This will be a big problem in the coming months as the recession worsens.
.
33, 000 households have missed their HDB mortgage payment for 3 months. 420,000 households have outstanding HDB loans.This means the default rate is aboutt 8% If HDB flats are affordable, why are so many people defaulting on their mortgages. Do we need an American style rescue package for these home owners - forgive part of their loans, lower interest rates and easier repayment terms.
.
In the US housing crisis, 5 million American home owners are affected out of a population of 300M people. We have about 3.5M people (residents), the 33K people who cannot afford to pay for their HDB + unknown number who cannot pay for private housing means we have a problem that has the same scale as the subprime crisis in terms of people not being able to service their mortgages.

The last time we compare the actions/performance of the PAP vs HK govt on minibonds - we find the situation quite embarassing for the PAP. Given the actions of the American govt to help households with their mortgage payments, if we start to compare...again it is "do-nothingness" vs proactive govt. 10,000 people losing their lifesavings can be treated like it is no big issue....33,000 households not able to pay HDB probably isn't a big issue for the PAP govt.
-----------------
33,000 flat owners owed HDB arrears of three months or more
[LINK]
Long term measures to help HDB mortgage defaulters is best solution By Cheryl Lim Mei Ling, Channel NewsAsia SINGAPORE : The Housing and Development Board (HDB) will continue to keep tabs on flat owners who default on their HDB mortgage payments. It stressed that long term measures to help these owners manage their mortgage payment is the best solution, and that compulsory acquisition of the flat is a last resort. As of October 2008, some 33,000 flat owners owed HDB arrears of three months or more. They make up less than 8 per cent of the 420,000 households with outstanding HDB loans. Giving this update in Parliament on Tuesday, Parliamentary Secretary for National Development Mohamad Maliki Osman said home owners should buy within their means. But he recognised that there are some who are affected by the economic downturn and one option for them is to downgrade to a smaller unit. More 2 and 3-room HDB flats will be coming on stream next year to cope with the growing demand for smaller flats. Dr Maliki also said heavily subsidised rental flats should be given to those who are in dire need. - CNA /ls

26 comments:

barttan said...

To downgrade from say a 4rm flat to 3rm, there will be a resale levy so whats the point of building more 2 or 3rm when turn left you are caught with 'some' policy and turn right also same thing. Sometimes, I wonder, have all this high flyers ever sit down and brainstorm for a better solution or just patching whenever some problems pop out.....

Anonymous said...

I am waiting with glee to see the property market crash and blood on the streets. Someone said it before, any real change in Spore will only happen through financial shocks. We are starting to see a series of them:, lehman minibonds, town council investments, stat board investments, and of course the perennial opaque GIC and Temasick.

Sgcynic said...

Long term measures to help HDB mortgage defaulters? Let's see...
1) Lengthen the mortgage repayment to 40 years.
2) Allow children and grandchildren to cover the mortgage loans
3) Job retraining - work two jobs instead of one

Clear eyed said...

Singaporeans are shock-proof. Even a river of blood on the street will not make them take the first step towards change.

yamizi said...

Will homeless and penniless increase the rate in crime?

Anonymous said...

yes yamizi, i think so.

i once read an interview of this millionaire from england. he grew up as an orphan. in his teenage years he lived from train stations to train stations. there was one time, when he was so hungry that he had to steal food. he wasn't proud of what he did but he said at that time, he was so hungry he had to do it to survive.

If you think about it, where does a homeless and hungry person turn to for help in Singapore?

Some rich people profess that there are many hands to help these unfortunate people in Singapore.

Well only time will tell. My guess is that crime rates will go up few years from now unless these people commit suicide.

young-pap said...

Singapore is doing great. The banks are doing well too - including the Overseas Chinese Banking Corporation (OCBC). Really!

So, please, do not let all these news influence your decision to invest or to park your money in Singapore.

Anonymous said...

You know what is my greatest fear? When election time comes along, the garmen throw a few goodies to us, all is forgotten and they continue with their rule.

Anonymous said...

in Sg, election is an illusion of choice and release valve for those innocent-eyed Sinkies. The despots and their cronies would have fixed any viable alternatives so that you won't have a real choice. They do not even put up pretences any more.

Anonymous said...

Over the next 6 to 9 months, the chances of this financial crisis degenerating into social unrest (anarchy even) in some countries is quite high.

When that happens, our MSM can surely be counted upon to feature the rioting scenes over and over, on front pages of print media as well as during tv news. The people will be frightened and wish for 'stability' to continue. The gahmen calls a quick election. Presto! Another 5 years in the bag for the miw, with a bigger 'mandate' to boot. Seems quite likely, doesn't it?

Anonymous said...

Hi Lucky! No update yet on Stat Board investment on structured products?

Anonymous said...

HDB decision to stop building 3-room flats is hurting flat-owners now. Yet they insisted it's the owners who bought flat without prudence. Very sad

Anonymous said...

i wondering if this is like the era of water margin where all the good guys (not in the govt) are suppressed by the cronies?

micky said...

Don't worry, here'll be many foreign talents in SG soaking up these defaulted HDB properties.

Web Design Company said...

Nice information, many thanks to the author. It is incomprehensible to me now, but in general, the usefulness and significance is overwhelming. Thanks again and good luck! Web Design Company

consoladores said...

Pretty effective piece of writing, much thanks for your article.

www.zaragoza-3d.com said...

Oh my god, there's a lot of worthwhile info here!

rocky case said...

Stephen Stapinski

Really your blog is very interesting.... it contains great and unique information. I enjoyed to visiting your blog. It's just amazing.... Thanks very much for the share.

Jasmine Siti Leong said...

My name is Jasmine Siti Leong from Singapore, i was in desperate need of a loan until i came across Lin Poh Loan Firm, i apply for the loan amount of S$120,000, the loan was granted to me without any stress, you can contact Lin Poh via Email:linpohloanfirm@yahoo.com.sg

PHUA AHMED said...


Hello,

Do you need a personal or business loan without stress and
Quick approval? If yes, contact us today as we are currently
Offering loans at superb interest rate of 2%. Our loan is
Secured and safe, our customers happiness is our strength.
For more information and Application, Please reply to us
With your information as below,
1)Full Names:...................
2)Country:......................
3)State:........................
4)Age: :........................
5)Sex:..........................
6)Phone Number:.................
7)Cell Phone:...................
8)Monthly income:.................
9)Loan Amount Needed:...........
10)Loan Duration:...............
Regards
Mr Phua Ahmed
Email: phuaahmed12@yahoo.com.sg

young lee said...


Hello, no proof necessary to support any person seen in
difficult situation,

This pluralistic view of international investment and led me for a new type of investment that is ready. In fact, I offer my services for individuals who are honest need support financial or create profitable business is to ensure a better tomorrow, with an estimated interest rate of 3% I want to tell I am willing to grant you a loan between 10,500 00 and more 95 500.00, I prepared for this capital of about 50. 550. 000.

So make loans to turn the capital, also has help me increase my dividends. In short, it is a little evidence I make many loans.

I would in any way violate the law on wear. I ready for any serious and honest person I could of course pay within a reasonable time. So if you are interested,

please contact me ASAP on my e-mail Personal: jingkohloanfirm@yahoo.com.sg (OR) jingkohloancompany.sg@gmail.com pour discussed in order to reach a possible agreement. In order to support someone in trouble. Please I write to this address is so I can explain the steps to follow to obtain a loan.

Your answer should contain the quantity you need, the usefulness of the loan monitoring contacts telephone.NB: My goal is to make loans to people in need, while like you. For more information please Contact by e-mail if you are interested in my offer loan for my email:jingkohloanfirm@yahoo.com.sg (OR) jingkohloancompany.sg@gmail.com

young lee said...


Hello, Sir/Madam

Thanks for contacting Jing Koh Assurance Loan Company Plc for your loan, Before we Proceed, i will

like to give you a brief history of the Company.

Jing Koh Assurance Loan Company plc is located at Accra Ghana#17 Crawford Street, W1, Westwood\'s

Liverpool. England Branch, This company came into existence since 1962 and was giving out mini loan

such as medical care loan, personal loan, e.t.c in 1962, Jing Koh Assurance went into stock exchange

Market to sell share to those who want to be partners in the company, as a registered company to

give out loan to all in England.

In 1962 Jing Koh Assurance Loan Company Plc was registered by the National Insurance Co-operation of

Company and Allied of Great Britain, to give out loan World wide, Since 1962 Jing Koh Assurance Loan

Company have been noted as the Giant in Capital/Investment Loan, Business Loan, Personal Loan,

Medical Care Loan, Mortgage Loan e.t.c.

We give out loan to all in need at a negotiable interest rate as low as 3% annual for any amount

Between $6,000.00 USD to $500,000 USD and Above for $5,000,000.00 USD,3% interest rate. Country of

origin is not a barrier to our loan service, provide you are not indicted by any court of

justice,Accreditation/Registed company.

For further enquirers/assistance do contact us 24 hours daily You Con Also Email.Us With This

jingkohloanfirm@yahoo.com.sg (OR) jingkohloancompany.sg@gmail.com

Anonymous said...

Hello loan seeker!
Are you facing any financial difficulties? Is your present situation not stable? Are you looking for a reliable source to get a loan with low interest rate? Then search no further because your problem is solved.
Alberto Loan Finance is your answer for loans. Do you need financial assistance to make your business function well? Need a loan, personal, Business or Student loan? And you do not know which loan firm to trust, where and how to get a loan from. An International Loans Company is here to offer you loan with low cost interest rate that you cannot have elsewhere. Loan interest rate is 3.0%
**********************************************************
Email: albertoloaninvestment@aol.com

young lee said...

Greetings..
Please contact us for your secure and unsecured Loan at an Interest rate of 3%
........................................

Is the difficulty of the economy affecting you this year, is your bank refuses to give you a loan

for this year? If your answer is yes, then you need a loan. I'm Mr Lee Chang, the owner of a

lending company We offer safe and secure loans at an interest rate of 3%.


* Are you financially squeezed?
* Do you seek funds to pay off credits and debts?
* Do you seek finance to set up your own business?
* Are you in need of private or business loans for various purposes?
* Do you seek loans to carry out large projects?

If you have any of the above problems, we can be of assistance to you but I want you to understand

that we give out loans at the interest rate of 3%.

* Borrow anything up to $95,000,000 USD.
* Choose between 1 to 20 years to repay.
* Choose between Monthly and Annual repayments Plan.
* Flexible Loan Terms.
Please if you are interested check back with us through this email

address:leechangloancompany.ch@gmail.com

We promise a 100% guarantee that you will receive your loan at the end of this loan

transaction.There is no security check, no credit check

Regards
Lee Chang
LEE CHANG LOAN COMPANY

mohamend loan said...


Do you need a Loan?
Are you looking for Finance?
Are you looking for a Loan to enlarge your business?
I think you have come to the right place.
We offer Loans atlow interest rate.
Interested people should please contact us on
For immediate response to your application, Kindly
reply to this emails below only.
mohamendloanservice@gmail.com

Please, do provide us with the Following information if interested.
1) Full Name:.........
2) Gender:.........
3) Loan Amount Needed:.........
4) Loan Duration:.........
5) Country:.........
6) Home Address:.........
7) Mobile Number:.........
8)Monthly Income:.....................
9)Occupation:...........................
)Which site did you here about us.....................
Thanks and Best Regards.
mohamendloanservice@gmail.com

www.mohammedloanserviceplc.com

Anonymous said...

We offer our Loans to our clients In USD($), GBP(£) Euro(€) or ($) Singapore Dollars and in the following categories.

Auto ,Mortgage ,Business ,Personal ,Real Estate Loan.

Contact us today for easy loan with less stress. We give out loans at low and affordable interest rate... Why waste more time? Contact us ASAP so we can move on with your request.

Contact us for more information with the Contact below,

Loan Agent: Peter White


Email: lim.koh56@yahoo.com

Thank you for your response.

Yours Faithfully,
Mr. Lim Koh(C.E.O).

LIM LOANS FIRM